Monday, June 23, 2008

Samuel Coleridge, Constancy to an Ideal Object

I found Coleridge’s work to be engaging as if I were a character is his poems, or his poems were written as letters to me. The most fascinating poem that Coleridge wrote is Constancy to an Ideal Object because it left me wondering what objects are most enjoyable in life.
The speaker in Constancy to an Ideal Object seems to be a lover away from his love, tormented and pleased by the dreams of what his life will be. He seems frustrated with his persistent thoughts on a consistent topic and pines,
Since all that beat about in Nature’s Range
Or veer or vanish; why shouldst thou remain
The only constant in a world of change
Oh yearning Thought! That liv’st but in the brain?” (349).


He treats thought, with a capital T (line 4), as if it is a spirit that is formed in the mind, and as it grows, possesses the body. I believe Coleridge uses this device as a way to sublimely allow the reader to “feel” what the narrator is feeling. But how can thought be so powerful that it can possess your mind? I believe this question calls the reader to recall a time when a thought consumed them so that nothing else in life could surpass it. How was the reader able to move pass that point in their life? How did they conquer the thought?

I believe this is what Coleridge is asking his reader to do. He wants us to think about being overtaken by thought, and how that thought changed or affected our lives. I have had many thoughts that seemed untamable, a point the narrator has come to. Coleridge wants the reader to become empathetic with the narrator.

But why is it important for the reader to empathize with the narrator? If the reader doesn’t sympathize with the narrator when he says, “…Yet still thou haunt’st me; and thought well I see/She is not thou, and only thou art she…” (349) we would only think he was crazy, and not realize that it is what we think that defines who we are. Though our thoughts are not always reality, they can define what our reality becomes.

Industrialism

With every change in life there is something lost or removed. In the case of Industrialism, the innocence of pastures and farms, family and country were swept away with the motions of the locomotive. In their place, social freedom and awareness, economic gain and power, technology came and dominated. After reading many writers from the Industrial Era, it is assumed that most had suspicion of the locomotives good for mankind and country. Though, the days of family and extended family may have been dwarfed, I can find no reasonable alternative to the locomotive coming into the lives of humans.

The locomotive was a powerful force in moving my things forward, women’s rights being one that began to move with great speed. After factory work became available the idea of the “factory girl,” the immoral promiscuous female, became a popular symbol for working women. Women who earned a living, helped to raise the economic standing of a nation were somehow the enemy, because they were “undermining the family structure” (487). Industrialization was widening the economic gap between the rich and the poor, and as in any time of ‘war’, women chipped in the close the gap so their families could eat. In essence women were told they weren’t needed. Their responsibility to industrialism and their country was to supply children for work, which the women could not feed. This made some women begin to look at the double-sided crazy talk of being a woman. It also made many people notice the effects factory work had on children.

Though working conditions were not ideal for women, children, or men; it was work. And many people needed the work to survive the times they were in. As, we do now. Those who do not work, do not eat; or eat very well.

Oscar Wilde, The Decay of Lying

The line between truth and untruth can be blurred in such a way one would question if there are any truths at all. Wilde’s play, the Decay of Lying, defined lying in a way to make one question if truth is even worth knowing. Does truth have to define the existence of man? Or is man free enough to define his own existence based on what he believes?

These questions tackled my own ideas of truth and untruth. Raised a Christian, I have always been taught to the “morbid and unhealthy faculty of truth-telling” (834), and have allowed it guide my thoughts and actions. Trained as a writer, I have always been taught truth is priority, but embellishment sells; even if that embellishment crosses the line into a lie. Admittedly, I have told some lies. Some I thought were pretty good, but according to Wilde, I might as well have told the truth. My lies didn’t stretch the boundaries even. They weren’t so random and fabricated that they crossed the line of so unbelievable that someone else had no choice but to believe it was true. That is the craft of the writer. And it is the reader’s responsibility to enjoy.

In the play, Vivian expresses that “art never expresses anything but itself. It has an independent life, just as Thought has, and develops purely on its own lines.” (845) I believe this statement embodies how Wilde felt about art itself. I think he wanted writers to be more creative and expanded their minds beyond what they could touch, taste, smell, and/or hear. He implies that it is the writer’s responsibility to produce something that many initially seem unreal, but as time continues, and people buy into, it becomes truth to all.

A great example of the fiction turning into fact is man going outer space. It was once an untruth that is was possible, but someone believed it was so, and now man has been to the moon and back. We are to continue in the direction and explore ideas and styles no one has done before.

Lord Alfred Tennyson, Tears, Idle Tears

We all grow old, unless we prematurely pass into death. Our deaths are not a variable in our life, but an ever present constant. We pass the time given as best we can, until that day arrives and we can no longer continue. During that process we think. We think of our present, our future, but above all, we think of our past.

Our past is our connection to the person we think we are, and the person we would like to be. It solidifies our connection to what is just and truth. Our past can cause us to yearn for what we once had, or search for what we do not. No poem I have read as expressed these notions s vividly as Tennyson’s Tears, Idle Tears. Tears…, is a poem that provokes the reader to think about the process of aging in a way that embraces life’s accomplishments and end with dignity and longing. However, to get to the point of embracing one’s end a recollection of one’s past is needed, and this poem provides the necessary steps to insure a happy transition.

“Tears, idle tears, I know not what they mean,
Tears from the depth of some divine despair
Rise in the heart, and gather to the eyes…” (597, lines 1-3)

I have never thought tears to be an idle element. It moves from Earth to human and back to Earth in a definite motion. But I do not think Tennyson wants us to believe that tears are idle in the sense or never moving or not actively being engaged. I believe he would like us to wonder the meaning behind our tears, why are they meaningless, or idle. That is where the recollection of the past comes in.

The narrator continues to rant about “the days that are no more” (597, lines 5, 10, 15, 20) and the “friends from the underworld” (597, line 7). All of the memories ride on the tide of the tear that finds its way to the narrator’s duct. But the tears do not move? Why? Why does the narrator not allow the tears to fall? I believe Tennyson wants to the reader to question why tears are the expression of internal turmoil. Tears do not cause friends to return or to flee. They cannot heal wounds or mend broken hearts. They cannot protect against death.

So, why do we need tears? I believe Tennyson is telling the reader we need tears to strengthen our ability to cope with the reality of life. Our tears do not compromise or strength. They are the vessels upon which tears move through our bodies.

Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Sonnet 32

Every lover needs to be exposed to Elizabeth Barrett Browning during their courtship experience. I wish I had been exposed to her explicit love poems before I wed. Her words, so vivid and rich, express all the feelings and emotions I felt during the time my husband began to woo me. It is as though Ms. Barrett Browning knowingly expressed my deepest cares for me, because she knew I would be unable to do so as lovingly as she was able to. For this, I express as great connection to her work. Especially, her Sonnet 32, because it expressed how there is no stronger feeling then that of love.

“The first time that the sun rose on thine oath
To love me, I looked forward to the moon
To slacken all those bonds which seemed too soon…” (531; lines 1-3)

Here, Barrett Browning is experiencing the world through the lens of love for the first time. In this world, consumed by raw emotion, all that is dark is cast away by the light love produces. In love, as with light, sickness cannot live; despair cannot grow. There is only enough room for love, the love that the two share for one another. I think this is an important aspect to pay attention to. The love between her and Robert Browning helped her escape her sick room, both mentally and physically. The sun that shines in line 1 is a metaphor for the sun that she had not seen for years being tucked away in her room. She was now free.

Though she was gaining a new sense of freedom from all that had imprisioned her, she was still captivated by the idea of being so withdrawn from the world. Would she have enough to offer Robert after being confined to her lounge chair for so long? Or is she too “out of tune” (531, line 7) to be a match for his lovely love? Is the love they share strong enough and/or worth giving up all that she would lose to be with him? Most people in the initial stages of love have asked themselves question similar to these, and I believe all can relate to her worry and her excitement.

Most people have even questioned if they deserve the love they feel.

“And, looking on myself, I seemed not one
For such man’s love!—more like an out-of tune
Worn viol, a good singer would be wroth” (531-532, lines 6-8)

But why does she question the love? Why can’t she just except that they belong together? Does their age difference mean that much to her? I believe Mrs. Browning suggests that love is a powerful force, which blinds the human of its capability to reason, and if looked at through too much haze could cause the heart to break and to hate. She was protecting herself from herself and the ills of a bad decision. But such is love. Ms. Browning could not have known what was ahead for her and her romance. She couldn’t have imagined that her life would be an example for many modern American women in love to follow. She helped the likes of Mariah Carey and Demi Moore feel comfortable in marrying men much younger than they are. Her example of courtship is a remarkable testimony to the power to love and to overcome.

Thursday, June 12, 2008

The Bronte Sisters & The Governess

I love reading literature about women with fortitude and moxy, and the stories/letters written by the Bronte sisters did not lead me yearning. There bold convictions and straightforward letters were filled with such emotion and self sureness that was/is unexpected of Victorian women. I was so taken back by there vivid approach to telling their dislikes for being a governess, I wondered if the duality of their lives and “thoughts” were not, somewhat, dangerous on many levels.

In public, the typical governess appeared to a meek, attentive whipping girl for her subjects and mistress. She had no thought or existence outside of household commands. Her every move and thought was controlled by the needs of the house. Or were they? Was the governess so dutiful, that she lost her wit and being in order for employment? According to the Bronte sisters’ letters, a governess is a woman who does what she must to survive in public, and in private is the woman she wishes to be.

It comes as no surprise that governesses were verbally abused by their mistresses. Though, the governess’s job seemed imprisoning, she had a freedom not bestowed to the lady of the household, because she was not, in essence, a lady.

A lady would have never been able to speak to her master as the character Agnes Grey, from Anne Bronte’s Agnes Grey, did and live without being beaten. Only a woman fed up with unruly children, a mistress with too much time, and an unforgiving master would be bold enough to say, “Then, sir, you must call them [the children] yourself, if you please…” (563) after her master insisted she wrangle his unruly children in from the snow, and not care the consequence. The beauty in her statement, though polite, is that it is against all the rules given by Sarah Stickney Ellis, because, again those rules were for “ladies.” Governesses weren’t ladies, they were simply governesses and they, without knowing, were smudging away at the definitions that defined women in general. Could the blurred social ranking of the governess be one of the pillars for women’s liberation?

Now, let us take a moment to speculate what Agnes Grey would have said had she been a modern woman in the movie The Nanny Diaries. I believe her monologue would have been similar to this:

“Then, sir, you must call them [the children] yourself, if you please, for they won’t listen to me…for all I care, the brats can catch a hellish cold or suffer from pneumonia. Frankly, I quit!”

Frankly, I would quit too. And because of the hardship suffered by these strong, enterprising ladies I have the right to.

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

The Lady of Shalott- Alfred Tennyson

It seems after reading both the 1830 and the 1833 versions of the Lady of Shalott, we are introduced to conflicting versions of the same woman. The woman in the original version seems whimsical, unstable. The more determined, self-sufficient heroine is described in the 1833 version. As a modern woman, I can’t help but to identify with the lady in the 1833 version. In both versions she is described as, “…the fairy Lady of Shalott” (lines 35-36, 590 text; lines 26-27 e-text). In theatre, fairies are usually a representation of youth, ignorance, and emotional turbulence. Many were often seen as the cause or the raw element of trouble. It is not hard to wonder if Tennyson deliberately characterized the Lady of Shalott as a fairy to emphasize her “curse.” Though neither lady, in either version, knows her curse or who/what cursed her, the consequences of their curse seem to have implications for completely different implications for the role of women.

In the 1830 version it was not until the Lady of Shalott overheard “…two young lovers lately wed…” (line 70, 590) did she express any resentment of having only seen people or their shadows through her mirror. She had not been as touched by religion (the Abbott in line 55), death (the funeral in line 67), or nature (the moon in line 69) as she was by the love the two newly weds shared. Why is their love, or love itself, so frustrating? Had love inspired Tennyson so, that he knew it would be the only thing to stir curiosity in the Lady? Or is it love, particularly love for a man, Tennyson uses to showcase how women are bound to men? I believe the latter.
It would not be farfetched to say that Tennyson, like most writers or educated males, would have been well exposed to the Bible. It is in the Bible that the first woman, Eve, is cursed to desire her husband. Eve, being the lifeline and representation for all women, passes this curse to every woman child. The Lady of Shalott would not have been an exception to this rule. Tennyson eludes to this in lines 109-117

“She left the web, she left the loom,
She made three paces thro’ the room,
She saw the water-lily bloom,
She saw the helmet and the plume,
She look’d down to Camelot.
Out flew the web and floated wide;
The mirror cracked from side to side;
‘The curse is come upon me,” cried
The Lady of Shalott. (1830 version)

The modern woman in me wants to believe this is another ploy for man, Tennyson, to disenfranchise woman, The Lady of Shalott. My mind is even allowed to oblige this thought when it is Sir Lancelot, the Lady of Shalott’s desire, who gives the unknown damsel importance and meaning in death because, “…she has a lovely face...” (593, line 169) and it is his blessing for “…God in his mercy lend her grace…” (593, line 170). Is Tennyson suggesting that woman has no meaning until man gives it to her? It is hard to say…however, Tennyson would not have revised the poem in the manner he did in the 1833 version.

In the 1833 version, Tennyson empowered the Lady to speak for herself, even in death; an honor most women would not have been allowed in reality or fiction.
“The web was woven curiously,
The charm is broken utterly,
Draw near and fear not---this is I,
The Lady of Shalott.” (e-text)

The lady’s level of self-respect and self-awareness seem to leap off of the page. She has plotted her own destiny. Had Tennyson began to see women and their role as humans differently, or was he expressing a belief he couldn’t in 1830? I believe that the Lady of Shalott’s death had nothing to do with feminism or traditionalism.

Though the curse of love, stemming from Eve, has not been broken the right for women to speak for themselves is transitionally unleashed from 1830 to 1833. That is the beauty of these poems; the same outcomes with different implications on the liberty of women to be human. An idea a modern woman can feel confident in passing on. I’m not sure if this was Tennyson’s objective when producing the 1833 revision, but I feel confident that he was sending us all a message that: life and death has everything to do with free will.